Gas Stove Ratings, A Repairman Ranks The Brands...

We have given each brand a rating of from 1 to 5 stars. A 5* rating means that, if we were shopping for a gas stove for our home, that is the brand we would choose (if it was available). When more than one brand has a 5* rating, we would choose the least expensive model.

For your convenience, we have also included the manufacturers' web addresses as well as our comments regarding the advantages/disadvantages of their products.

AARROW---------------aarowfires.com------------<1* This brand is from ARADA LTD. and is available throughout Europe. The SHERBORNE units use the conventional flue which is less efficient. They are available in sizes from 2-4.8kw and with either a log or coal bed for the desired look and feel. They have a U.K. stockist locator on their website to help you to find an authorized dealer but the guarantee is not as good as many brands.

AMERICAN HEARTH------americanhearth.com--------<1* This brand is a division of EMPIRE COMFORT SYSTEMS INC. and the stoves are available in the U.S. The HERITAGE series units are available in both unvented (not recommended) and direct vented models. They feature cast iron construction and traditional styling. They use a ceramic burner for realistic fires and offer options such as a blower, remote control, or wall thermostat. They have a dealer locator by zip code on their website but the warranty on the units is not very good when compared to other brands.

APPALACHIAN STOVE----appalachianstove.com------<1* The CONQUEST ELITE models are small basic units that are sold through dealers. Their website is not much help and the warranty on the heat exchanger is not good.

AVALON---------------avalonfirestyles.com------<1* This brand is from TRAVIS INDUSTRIES INC and is available in the United States. The units are direct vented for added efficiency and safety and have a heating capacity of 31000 btu/hr. They offer a range from the classic cast iron look and feel to the modern bay window looks. The units use millivolt controls so they can operate during a power outage. Their patented EMBER-FYRE ceramic burner provides realistic looking wood fires. They have a dealer locator by zip code on their website but the warranty on the units is not very good.

BARBAS---------------barbas.nl-----------------<1* These units are from INTERFOCOS and are available in Europe. The ECO models feature a modern look and feel and are direct vented for efficiency and safety. They can be controlled manually or with a thermostat. The CANTERBURY units offer a more traditional cast iron look. They have a dealer locator by country on their website but the warranty on the units is not as good as other brands.

BLAZE KING-----------blazeking.com-------------<1* This brand is manufactured in Canada by VALLEY COMFORT SYSTEMS and in the U.S.A. by BLAZE KING INDUSTRIES. The TORINO MODEL 1605 is available in either intermittent or standing pilot versions. They feature a variable speed convection fan and a wireless remote control with built in thermostat. They have a dealer locator on their website to help you to find an authorized retailer. The warranty on the heat exchanger is prorated which is not as good as many brands.

BRECKWELL------------breckwell.com-------------<1* This brand is from NATIONAL STEELCRAFTERS OF OREGON INC. (NSO) and is available in the U.S. and Canada. They offer a variety of models in either B VENT (natural draught) or direct vent models. They have a dealer locator map on their website but the warranty on the units is not very good.

BROSELEY-------------broseleyfires.com---------<1* This brand is available in the U.K., Ireland, Cyprus, France, and Germany. They offer a wide range of cast iron units for the traditional look and feel. They also offer an unvented (portable) model which could have adverse health effects. They have a store locator by postcode on their website but the warranty on the units is not good.

BUCK STOVE-----------buckstove.com-------------<1* This brand is available in the United States. The TOWNSEND II DV model is a direct vent, cast iron unit that has a heating capacity of up to 31000btu/hr. The units feature a thermostatically controlled variable speed blower and a millivolt gas valve. They offer a wall thermostat and a hand held remote thermostat as options. They have a dealer locator by zip code on their website but the warranty on the units is not very good.

COMFORT GLOW---------comfortglowheat.com-------<1* This brand is from DESA HEATING LLC. and is available in the United States The BURLINGTON PEDESTAL models are basic thermostatically controlled units. They offer an optional blower for improved air circulation. The units are sold through dealers as well as at HOME DEPOT and DO IT BEST centers. The warranty is not good and the units are unvented which can cause health issues.

CONTINENTAL-----continentalfireplaces.com------<1* This brand is from WOLF STEEL LTD. and is available in North America. They offer a wide variety of units in both traditional and modern styles. They are only sold through dealers and the warranty is not very good when compared to other brands.

DIK GEURTS-----------geurts.nl-----------------<1* These units feature modern styling and are available in Europe. They are direct vent units for efficiency and safety. The manufacturers' website has a dealer locator by country with links but is not much help and does not have a stated warranty policy.

DOVRE----------------dovre.co.uk---------------<1* These units are available in Europe and feature traditional cast iron styling. They are available in conventional flue (B vent) or balanced flue (direct vent) models. They offer either log or coal effects but the warranty on the units is not very good.

DRU------------------drugasar.co.uk------------<1* This brand features a wide variety of models and is available in Europe. The SOLO units feature direct venting and modern styling. The PRONTO units are wall hung and offer three sides of glass for excellent viewing of the fire effects. The warranty on the units is not as good as many options.

DUTCH WEST-----------vermontcastings.com-------<1* This brand is from VERMONT CASTINGS which is a part of MONESSEN HEARTH SYSTEMS CO. They offer basic cast iron units that are available in North America and Asia. They are available as direct vent or natural draft models and feature a durable radiant ceramic burner system. They have a dealer locator on their website but the warranty on the units is not very good when compared with other brands.

ENGLANDER------------englandsstoveworks.com----<1* This brand is from ENGLANDS STOVE WORKS INC. They offer a wide range of units but they are vent free and could cause or aggravate health concerns. They are sold at many hardware, home improvement, and farm/home stores.

ENVIRO---------------enviro.com----------------<1* This brand is made in Canada and is available in North America and Europe. The CARA line features direct vent units with european styling while the EG28 & 40 models feature a modern bay window look and feel. They also offer cast iron models for the traditional look. They have a dealer locator by country and zip/postal code on their website. The warranty on the heat exchanger is not very good when compared to other brands.

FLANDRIA-------------flandriaheating.com-------<1* This brand is from SAEY HOME & GARDEN NV and is available in Europe and South Africa. The SKI models are B VENT units with a modern look and feel. They feature electronic ignition and thermostatic regulation but the guarantee on the units is not very good. They have a dealer locator by country on their website to help you to find a retailer.

GAZCO----------------stovax.com----------------<1* This brand is available in Europe. They feature a wide range of units in both traditional cast iron looks as well as contemporary styles. They offer natural draught, powered flue, or balanced flue venting units to meet every conceivable application. The warranty on the units (especially the heat exchanger) is not very good.

HAMPTON------------ hampton-fire.com ---------4* This brand is made in Canada by FIREPLACE PRODUCTS INTERNATIONAL LTD and is sold in North America and Australia. They offer basic cast iron units, in three sizes, for the traditional look and feel. They offer options such as a variable speed blower, remote controls, and wall thermostats. The units are backed by a very good guarantee and they have a dealer locator by country and zip/postal code on their website.

HARMAN---------------harmanstoves.com----------<1* This brand is from HEARTH & HOME TECHNOLOGIES and is available in North America, France, Ireland, and New Zealand. The FIRELUXE models feature traditional cast iron looks and have a cooktop burner. The CLARITY series units feature a modern bay window look and are available in either B VENT or direct vent models. The warranty on the heat exchanger is not very good.

HEARTHSTONE----------hearthstonestoves.com-----<1* This brand is available in Canada and the U.S.A. They offer a wide variety of models that are thermostatically controlled. They offer optional remote controls and blower kits. The TUCSON VF models are vent free stoves and receive a <1* rating. They have a dealer locator by zip/postal code to help you to purchase the units.

HEAT&GLO-------------heatnglo.com---------------2* This brand is from HEARTH & HOME TECHNOLOGIES which is a subsidiary of HNI CORP. The PALOMA models are European-style units while the TIARA models feature traditional cast iron style units that are available in three sizes. The units feature their "INTELLIFIRE" ignition system which is an intermittent pilot ignition system where the pilot is lit automatically when there is a call for heating. All of the units are direct vented for efficiency and safety. The units are backed by a good warranty and they have a dealer locator on their website.

JOTUL----------------jotul.com-----------------<1* The Classic line features cast iron models in either B vent or direct vent. The units use millivolt controls so that they can operate during a power outage. The GF370DV models have a modern look and feel. They feature an intermittent pilot system to save on gas and have automatic modulation. The units feature a variable speed blower and include a remote control. They have a dealer locator on their website but the warranty on the heat exchanger of the units is not very good.

KINGSMAN-------------kingsmanind.com-----------<1* This brand is made in Canada and available in the U.S. as well. The FDV300 is a basic unit with options for a convection blower and wall mount or remote controls. The units are sold through dealers and offer a very good warranty on the heat exchanger but for most other parts it is not very good. The FVF models are vent free units and could possibly cause health issues.

KOZI-----------------kozistoves.com------------<1* This brand is manufactured in Canada by APR INDUSTRIES LTD and is available in North America and Europe. The DV1 units use direct venting for maximum efficiency and safety. They are thermostatically controlled and feature a two speed blower. The warranty on the heat exchanger is very good but for most other parts it is not as good as many brands.

LENNOX---------------lennoxhearthproducts.com--<1* The EPIC models are larger units that feature a bay window for better viewing of the flames and a variable speed blower. The SEREFINA models feature vintage cast iron styling while the VISION models offer three sided glass and European styling. They have a dealer locator by zip/postal code.

LOPI-----------------lopistoves.com------------<1* This brand is from TRAVIS INDUSTRIES INC. They offer a variety of direct vent models and include a kit for LP gas as standard on all the units. Their "EMBER-FYRE" ceramic burner base provides a very realistic look and feel. They offer an optional aromatherapy kit which is a tray that allows you to put scented oils in it. They have a dealer locator by zip code on their website but the warranty on the heat exchanger is not as good as many brands.

MAJESTIC-------------majesticproducts.com------<1* This brand is from MONESSEN HEARTH SYSTEMS CO. and is available in the U.S. and Canada. They offer vent free models with a traditional cast iron look and feel. There can be some adverse health effects from unvented units.

MANTIS---------------empirecomfort.com----------5* This brand is from EMPIRE COMFORT SYSTEMS and is available in the U.S., Canada, and South America. The units are unmatched in heating efficiency with an AFUE of 93%. They can be vented with pvc pipe for flexible and fast installation. The units humidify the homes' air during operation by capturing the water produced due to the high efficiency combustion. This water is then pumped to a tray where it is evaporated and then sent into the room. The units feature hot surface ignition and a three speed temperature controlled fan. They have a dealer locator by zip code for the U.S. and a list with links for other countries. The units are also backed by a very good guarantee.

MENDOTA--------------mendotahearth.com---------<1* This brand is from JOHNSON GAS APPLIANCE COMPANY and is available in the U.S. and Canada. The MEDALLION models are available in two sizes (30000 and 40000 btu/hr) and are direct vented for efficiency and safety. They have a bay window for better viewing of the flames and offer remote control kits. They have a dealer locator by map or zip/postal code on their website. The warranty on the heat exchanger is very good but for most other parts it is not as good as many brands.

NAPOLEON-------------napoleonfireplaces.com-----3* This brand is available in North America, Europe, and the Middle East. They offer a wide variety of units in both traditional cast iron looks and modern styles. They also offer vent free units but they only receive a <1* rating. The warranty on the units is very good and they have a dealer locator on their website.

NESTOR MARTIN--------nestormartin.be-----------<1* This brand is available worldwide and features a wide variety of units. They use a patented fully ceramic burner for durability but the guarantee on the units is not as good as most brands.

OSBURN------------- osburn-mfg.com ----------<1* These units are from STOVE BUILDER INTERNATIONAL (SBI). They are available in North America, New Zealand, and Australia. They feature B vent units as well as direct vent models. They are basic models with a modern bay window and a variable speed convection blower. The warranty on the units is not very good when compared to other brands.

QUADRA-FIRE----------quadrafire.com-------------2* This brand is from HEARTH & HOME TECHNOLOGIES and features units in small, medium, and large sizes in both traditional and contemporary styles. The units are all direct vented for efficiency and safety and feature their "TRUE GLOW" very realistic ceramic burner. The units are backed by a good warranty and they have a dealer locator on their website for your convenience.

REGENCY------------ regency-fire.com ---------4* This brand is from FIREPLACE PRODUCTS LTD. and the units feature the best warranty in the industry. Their ULTIMATE LINE features B vent models as well as direct vent units. They have a worldwide dealer locator by country on their website.

SAEY-----------------saeyheating.com-----------<1* This brand features a wide variety of basic units from traditional cast iron to modern styles. They are B vent models which means that they take combustion air from the inside of the home and therefore are a less efficient way of heating the home.

SCAN-----------------scan.dk-------------------<1* The SCAN 2 units are direct vent models for efficiency and safety. They feature a stainless steel burner for durability. Most of the parts on the units are backed by a very good warranty but the coverage for the heat exchanger is not as good as most brands.

SUMMERS HEAT---------englandsstoveworks.com----<1* This is another brand from ENGLANDS STOVE WORKS INC. They offer a wide variety of vent free units that are sold at hardware and home centers. This type of unit can cause or aggravate health issues.

THELIN---------------thelinco.com--------------<1* This brand is available in the U.S. and features units in the old pot belly style. The PARLOUR 3000 models have a heat output of up to 31000 btu/hr and a variable speed fan. The warranty on the units is not very good.

TIMBER RIDGE---------englandsstoveworks.com----<1* This is another brand name from ENGLANDS STOVE WORKS INC. They offer a wide range of vent free units but this type of unit can have adverse health effects. The units are sold at many hardware and home improvement retailers.

VANGUARD-------------vanguardheat.com----------<1* This brand is from DESA INTERNATIONAL and features basic cast iron units for the traditional look. They offer both vented and vent free stoves but their warranty is not as good as many brands.

VERMONT CASTINGS-----vermontcastings.com-------<1* This brand is a part of MONESSEN HEARTH SYSTEMS CO. and is available in North America and Asia. They offer a wide variety of basic units but the warranty is not as good as many brands. They have a dealer locator on their website to help you to find an authorized retailer.

VILLAGER-------------villager.co.uk------------<1* This brand is from LYME REGIS ENGINEERING CO. LTD. and is available in the U.K. They offer both conventional and balanced flue (direct vent) models. The warranty on most parts is very good but the heat exchanger coverage is not.

WANDERS--------------wanders.com---------------<1* This brand is made in the Netherlands and available in Europe. They offer wall mounted units as well as the traditional free standing units. The units are direct vent for efficiency and safety but the warranty is not very good.

YEOMAN------------- yeoman-stoves.co.uk -----<1* These units are available in the U.K. They are available in either conventional flue or balanced flue models and offer either coal or log effects. They feature traditional styling and offer either a flat top or a canopy. The warranty on the units is not very good when compared to other brands.
Return from gas stove ratings to home